The Wax Museum

The Wax Museum

The Second Annual Waxies! 🏆

The Wax Museum Award Show is live!

Jan 03, 2025
∙ Paid

Ladies and gentlemen, it’s time once again for the biggest night in niche music curation! Welcome to the Second Annual Waxies, where we present our coveted Waxy trophies to the albums and artists who captured the spirit of the past year in music, culture, and that sweet, sweet wax.

Before we begin, this is LAST CALL to save any songs from our two ever-evolving playlists — Album of the Year Leaderboard (Spotify | Apple) and The Best Songs of the Year (Spotify | Apple). They’ll be completely refreshed for 2025 soon, so grab your favorites now while you can.

Last week, we revealed our top 10 albums of 2024 and, for the truly dedicated among you, released an entire book documenting the top 100. Now we’re delving further into that list (and beyond) to shine a spotlight on the year’s best.

You’ll find the 30-song Waxies playlist at the end of this newsletter, featuring every winner we’re about to honor. Turn it up and let’s celebrate the records that made 2024 one for the ages!


Rookie of the Year

The Waxy goes to: Wishy - Triple Seven

Get Vinyl: Tomato Red | Jackpot Gold | Black

2024 was bursting with incredible debut albums — artists like Mk.gee, Friko, English Teacher, The Last Dinner Party, Sprints, Been Stellar, and julie all made waves and earned their spots on our 100 Best Albums list. But the standout for me was Indianapolis rockers Wishy.

Triple Seven is a nostalgia-soaked love letter to the ’90s, brimming with shimmering guitars and hopelessly romantic lyrics. With Kevin Krauter and Nina Pitchkites splitting vocal and songwriting duties, they’ve nailed a sound that feels timeless yet fresh.


Sophomore Slump Buster of the Year

The Waxy goes to: Being Dead - EELS

Get Vinyl: Speckled Dragon Egg

The sophomore album can be a daunting hurdle, forcing artists to either refine their debut sound or boldly reinvent it. For Austin duo Being Dead, the choice was clear: crank up the weirdness. EELS is a chaotic, genre-hopping fever dream that’s as ambitious as it is unpredictable.

From lush, Beach Boys-inspired harmonies to Animal Collective-esque bursts of experimental chaos, EELS revels in its beautiful messiness. It’s an album that refuses to sit still — if you’re looking for something that constantly surprises, EELS is a must-spin.


Double Stuffed Album of the Year

The Waxy goes to: Cindy Lee - Diamond Jubliee

Get Vinyl: Black

Cindy Lee (Patrick Flegel of Women) has delivered a monumental achievement with Diamond Jubilee: a sprawling, 32-track, two-hour double album that seems daunting to many in our TikTok-length-attention-span era.

But once you track it down and hit play, you’re hooked. This lo-fi, psych-rock masterpiece expertly balances the accessible and the avant-garde, weaving lush, nostalgic tales of love and longing into a kaleidoscopic soundscape. It’s bold, immersive, and worth the effort.

It’s no surprise that Pitchfork already crowned Diamond Jubilee the third-best album of the decade. And for those who want to dive deeper, don’t miss Sam Westpy’s song by song breakdown.


All Killer No Filler Album of the Year

The Waxy goes to: Glitterer - Rationale

Get Vinyl: Orange | Black

Not everyone has 2 hours for a lo-fi opus. Sometimes you just have 20 minutes, which is the enough time for Ned Russin’s Rationale, under his Glitterer moniker.

With 12 tracks in 21 minutes, Rationale packs a punch. Think '90s grunge infused with the dreamy, ethereal haze of fuzzed-out noise pop. The lyrics are simple yet strikingly vulnerable, cutting straight to the heart and giving Glitterer a distinctive edge in a crowded field.


I Said Yep, What a Concept Album of the Year

User's avatar

Continue reading this post for free, courtesy of Jared Smith.

Or purchase a paid subscription.
© 2026 The Wax Museum · Privacy ∙ Terms ∙ Collection notice
Start your SubstackGet the app
Substack is the home for great culture